Wednesday May 23, 2012 11:44 PM AEST

Mouse beats Xbox 360

By Nathan Lawrence
12:22 Feb 17, 2011 | 15 Comments
Tags: console | controller | versus | pc | mouse | and | keyboard | feature
 »
Mouse beats Xbox 360

The humble mouse and keyboard is still THE best gaming control option - and it might be coming to a console near you!

PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 and PC sit in a bar enjoying a drink after a hard day's gaming. They talk about the weather, the local digital sports team and more than a few jokes at Wii's expense are thrown in for good measure.

As evening becomes night, PlayStation 3, the slick hipster of the group, bangs the table. "I'm taking game controls to the next level with my buddy Move. The accuracy is a whole lot better than Wii's and we're actually integrating it into some real gaming titles."

Xbox 360, the everyday man, finishes his beer and shakes his head. "All you've done is reinvent the motion-controlled wheel! I'm evolving game controls with my mate Kinect. Players don't even need to hold anything in their hands to interact with us and they can play games with full-body movements."

PC, the George Clooney of the trio, enjoys his beer while the other two continue to fight among themselves. Eventually they realise that PC hasn't contributed to their argument.

"How can you sit there so quietly, PC? You haven't evolved past your keyboard and mouse roots since your platform began," says PlayStation 3.

PC finishes the last of his beer and smiles. "Why on Earth would I ever need to ‘evolve' my keyboard and mouse control methodology? It gets the job done and is still infinitely more accurate and versatile than anything you two have to throw at it."

Ba-dum. Tish.

In all seriousness, having had quite a lot of hands-on time across the board with various console controllers-including the afore-joked-about Move and Kinect-everything is still compared to the rock-hard foundation of the keyboard+mouse combo. And still, to this day, every controller that doesn't include mouse aiming, is a silver medal at best; and a none-too-shiny medal at that.

Sure, there may be exceptions to this rule. Racing games, sports titles and third-person games that don't require accurate ranged aiming all work really well on a controller; arguably, they work better than the PC's base control methodology. But when it comes to any title that requires a merging of speed and accuracy, where fast reactions need to be complemented by a controller that can match the rate at which you react in your mind, nothing beats the keyboard/mouse combo. In more specific terms, we find it incredibly frustrating in a console first-person shooter when we can't move or react in the same way that we can on a PC.

We recently had some hands-on time with a couple of different Xbox 360 third-party controllers: one was more or less the same as the first-party controller, but another one made use of a modified PC mouse for aiming. Needless to say, the latter controller had us interested.

The Aimon XB is separated into two parts: one part is the aforementioned mouse (with four thumb-positioned buttons for A, B, X and Y functionality), while the other is similar to a Wii Nunchuck controller. The ‘Nunchuck' replaces the functionality of the left-hand side of an Xbox 360 controller, while the mouse takes over the right-hand side.

 
 »
 
Aliens: Colonial Marines in depth; Z-77 Motherboard round-up; strategy gaming special; Home Server tutorial. PLUS MUCH MORE - ON SALE NOW!
15 Comments
nukejockey
Feb 17, 2011 3:33 PM
Not bad, expensive though I bet. And when it comes to MW2, if you're gonna play it with a mouse and keyboard, might as well play it online.
somemadcaaant
Feb 17, 2011 5:50 PM
Using the consoles auto aim in every game, its like a pc player with a bot lol

Frag controller and xfps suffered from uncontrollable lag on the z access, tho it's what u get used to i guess like the kid in the vid, mouse resolution must be set to max dpi by the looks of it, hardly moving that mouse.

-smc
SceptreCore
Feb 17, 2011 10:15 PM
Love mouse and keyboard. Best controller config you can get... except for racing.
Acintai
Feb 17, 2011 10:47 PM
what sceptre said. Oh and joysticks for air sims.
orcone
Feb 17, 2011 11:10 PM
Honestly, this is the main reason I'm so hesitant about consoles.
If they natively support keyboard and mouse combos, I'll buy it and use it non-stop.
Acintai
Feb 17, 2011 11:32 PM
yeh but a console isnt really a console without controls, with keyboard/mouse support all the keyboard/mouse people will own the people with the controllers and so everyone will want keyboard/mouse and it'll simply be a pc.
thesorehead
Feb 18, 2011 12:10 AM
+1 to kb/m being superior in every way for first person and other speed/accuracy games (bejeweled, diablo, ... etc). Console controls are definitely better for racing, platformers and other genres.

Whenever I play FPS on console I always leave autoaim on. And it's still nowhere near as good as using a kb/mouse.
bastard
Feb 18, 2011 2:41 PM
I dunno, I have thought about KB/M on consoles for a long time and find the whole idea to be unpalitable. The KB/M combo is a much better control scheme by far that sadly, isnt suited the play area of where most consoles are situated. I do realise that a number of people have their consoles in their bedrooms next to their comp, but I would say that most have it in their main entertainment area.

One of the main reasons I found consoles to be appealing is that they are a level playing field. Same frames per second, same level of detail, same controller. To me this just seems like another level of tampering for people that don't want to learn the to use a controller and worse, it can't be detected.

As has been demonstrated, it gives COD a bigger advantage and as far as I can see, it will do the same for all other FPSs. So you will have two groups of people, the ones that use the KB/M adaptors and the ones that no longer want to play in an environment that they can't win.

Anyway, I am sure time will tell.

King_TriTAN
Feb 20, 2011 10:33 AM
[quote]
Racing games, sports titles and third-person
[/quote]
And anything involving brawling feels more tactile on a controller, to say that the M/KB is the best controller also implies that FPS and RTS are the best genres.

Actually I would say TPS does require accurate aiming.
hicsy
Feb 20, 2011 1:54 PM
AimOn terrible, I bought one on the advice of a mate who said it have amazing reviews... after trying to set up the mouse (I thought I was doing something wrong when it wouldnt sync) I read the forums, and found out that the constant drop-outs was considered 'normal' (btw small movements do work VERY WELL, but it just drops out so rapidly that its sometimes like you only have 100dpi), with the AimOn team praising one guys efforts of hard-wiring an AC power supply and modifying the wireless connection to corded just to get a sync lasting more than one game... EA games releasing games before they should even be Beta - EAT YOUR HEART OUT! there is a new contender for the wooden spoon and their name is AimOn
Metasynaptic
Feb 21, 2011 9:13 AM
Errr... aren't Xbox360 and PS3 USB devices? Why is the concept of developing a set of mouse/keys drivers for these platforms such a far out concept.
Jombib
Feb 21, 2011 12:47 PM
Also if your going to hook your console up to your pc monitor and play with a keyboard and mouse why not just play your pc? Keyboard and mouse don't so work well on a sofa in the lounge.
hicsy
Feb 22, 2011 3:57 PM
yeah, i think its just because the console is more convenient in a common loungeroom, i use a steelseries mousepad in the loungeroom
the console GAMES themselves are written for joystick-devices though... so what you have is an mediator between, reading how far the mouse has moved recently, and converting that into a joystick equivalent for the game... not so accurate as it doesnt really know frame-rates etc hence, the different firmware for each game
Waltish
Feb 24, 2011 12:40 AM
Hmmm ... Well why is it being touted as if the XPox is doing something new, PS3 has Had support for KB & M in some games from the get go,http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=ps3+keyboard+and+mouse&aq=f

and SplitFish also have had a nunchuck and mouse input device for the PS3 for Ages.

http://www.splitfish.com/

{:)

BookWorm.303
Feb 24, 2011 4:18 PM
I was born with a Gameboy pocket Glod in my hand thank you very much
Comments have been disabled on this article.
 
Atomic Magazine

Issue: 137 | June, 2012

Atomic is a magazine aimed squarely at computer enthusiasts, gamers, and serious PC upgraders.

Every month we bring you the latest reviews of new technology and PC components, in depth features on everything from overclocking to console hacking, and gaming previews and interviews.
 
Latest Comments
 
Latest User Reviews
Battlefield 3 is the new benchmark online FPS
90%
A very fun and realistic multiplayer ride.
 
Antec Kuhler 920 - liquid cool
90%
Antec Kuhler 920 silent but effientive out of the box no maintence water cooling kit
 
Antec's Lanboy Air - our new favourite case
90%
Antec Lan boy Air in red a very cool design
 
Antec's Lanboy Air - our new favourite case
90%
This product overall is awesome.
 
MSI's GT780 laptop as fast as it gets
90%
Nice laptop