CPUs, Motherboards & RAM
Graphics Cards
Peripherals
Modding & Cooling
Systems
Networking
Security
Operating Systems
PC Games
Console Games
Atomic.edu
Tutorials
Lifestyle
Entertainment
Science
Merchandise
Wallpapers
Revolver Melbourne 2011
Revolver Sydney 2011
Atomic Unlocked 2010
Power to the PC Tour 2010
Industry Events
Login
|
Register
|
RSS
News
|
Reviews
|
Features
|
Podcasts
|
Opinions
|
Galleries
|
Videos
|
Competitions
|
Newsletter
|
Subscribe
Friday February 10, 2012 1:52 PM AEST
Atomic MPC
>
Features
>
Geek
>
Lifestyle
>
Safari 3.01 Beta for Windows
Lifestyle
Safari 3.01 Beta for Windows
By
James Matson
09:59 Jun 20, 2007
Tags:
Safari
|
3.01
|
Beta
|
for
|
Windows
|
firefox
|
comparison
Tweet
Comment Now
«
Page 1
Page 2
Page 3
»
Related Articles
Kinect hitting PC in February, as Steve Ballmer loses it at CES
Futuremark announce 3DMark for Windows 8 PCs and Tablets
Diablo III beta impressions - MOAR CLICKS
Battlefield 3 MP beta starting this month!
The Comparison
While Safari looks nice, we all know that the meat of the matter is performance. Even those few milliseconds of render time saved in one browser might put it head and shoulders over others. In order to get a good feel for how Safari stacks up against the competition, we ran some benchmarking against popular Windows browsers, namely Internet Explorer 7, Opera 9.21 and Firefox 3 (Minefield Alpha).
With the goal of being as true to typeface standards as possible, Safari on Windows sacrifices clarity and sharpness in favour of rounded lettering. Note in particular bolded characters tend to bleed into each other more.
Microsoft is happy to squash the shape of each letter into the pixel boundaries of the screen. This improves on-screen readability in browsers that maintain the Windows default rendering algorithm, but you lose out on the subtle differences between font types at smaller sizes.
The Performance
While it’s difficult to truly form concrete opinions when benching a Beta versus final products (and even an Alpha) it still provides a sense of what we’re in for. We wanted to know the footprint on the system, such as the install size and memory usage, as well as what deviations there were in download speed, standards compliance and CSS rendering. All testing was done on with the following set up - Win XP SP2, Core2 Duo E6300, 2GB DDR2 memory and each test ran 3 times for average results.
Internet Explorer 7
Firefox 3 (Minefield) Alpha
Opera 9.21
Safari 3.0 (Beta)
Install Size
3.44MB
22.2MB
5.19MB
27.5MB
Memory Usage
38,032KB
29,768KB
23,876KB
50,592KB
MSU Speed Test (1MB file)
10.4 seconds
12.3 seconds
23.6 seconds
Unknown
CSS Rendering Test
250ms
234ms
219ms
31ms
Page load (cnn.com)
11.2 seconds
10.9 seconds
11.1 seconds
9.1 seconds
Acid 2 Test
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
Google Image search “Laserz”
7.3 seconds
6.3 seconds
14.9 seconds
3.6 seconds
So what have we learned? In both memory usage and install Safari is the fatty of the group, which in terms of install size could be indicative of the fact Apple has tried to bundle no less than three other products with the browser, Quicktime, Bonjour and Apple Update. Nasty. Our CSS rendering test comprised of the load time for a page containing roughly 2500 positioned DIVs, with Safari winning out ever so slightly on speed. Safari fared well in a load time comparison for a Google Image search, snappily bringing up a page of associated pictures 2.9 seconds faster than Firefox and leaving Opera for dust.
All the browsers bar IE7 passed the Acid 2 test (a render check for web standards).
The MSU speed test which gives you the total time of a 1MB download, had to be given an ‘unknown’ rating. The MSU speed test and Safari don’t play well together at this point, with the website reporting that on a 1500Kbps ADSL connection, it took 0.0324 seconds to download 1MB. Well, we can dream can’t we?
Where Apple really likes to sound the horn is in relation to Javascript execution time, their website claiming execution of JavaScript up to 2.8 times faster than Internet Explorer 7 and up to 1.6 times faster than Firefox.
Our benchmark – using the jsspeed.php webpage, revealed they aren’t actually far off the mark with Opera the only serious competition.
Internet Explorer 7
Firefox 3 (Minefield) Alpha
Opera 9.21
Safari 3.0 (Beta)
Javascript Speed Test
1500ms
828ms
235ms
187ms
Safari certainly seems to have the guts of a good browser inside it, offering speed where it’s paramount - the rendering of text and images.
«
Page 1
Page 2
Page 3
»
Behind the scenes with Mass Effect 3! GTX 560 VGA round-up! Essential Skyrim tweaks to improve your game! Plus reviews, news, hardware, more games, and easy to following modding guides for PC builders. ON SALE NOW!
Purchase your copy now - only $8.95 including postage
Subscribe to our digital version - only $49.95 a year
Email this
Print this
Tweet this
Send us your tips
Ads by Google
You must be a registered member of Atomic to post a comment.
Click here to login
|
Click here to register
Five things that could kill Mass Effect 3
HD7970 vs GTX 780: the future of graphics cards in 2012
The Darkness
Creation Kit and Steam Workshop for Skyrim go live, Texture Pack released
PS3 pwns retail, while Xbox also... pwns... huh?
Powered by Disqus
Latest Competitions
Thermaltake kicks off your gaming year with a BANG
Thermaltake has started off the new year with a bang by giving away a Tt eSport Theron Laser mouse to not one or two, but TWENTY lucky Atomicans!
Atomic Magazine
Issue:
133
|
February, 2012
Atomic
is a magazine aimed squarely at computer enthusiasts, gamers, and serious PC upgraders.
Every month we bring you the latest reviews of new technology and PC components, in depth features on everything from overclocking to console hacking, and gaming previews and interviews.
What's in this issue?
Subscribe Now
Buy this issue
Digital Version
Latest Comments
Powered by Disqus
Latest User Reviews
90%
Battlefield 3 is the new benchmark online FPS
A very fun and realistic multiplayer ride.
By
Periander
|
10:59 Nov 20, 2011
90%
Antec Kuhler 920 - liquid cool
Antec Kuhler 920 silent but effientive out of the box no maintence water cooling kit
By
mattleyland
|
14:23 Oct 28, 2011
90%
Antec's Lanboy Air - our new favourite case
Antec Lan boy Air in red a very cool design
By
mattleyland
|
12:55 Oct 28, 2011
90%
Antec's Lanboy Air - our new favourite case
This product overall is awesome.
By
Provodnik14
|
10:43 Oct 16, 2011
90%
MSI's GT780 laptop as fast as it gets
Nice laptop
By
daryl.cheshire
|
00:53 Oct 4, 2011
more user reviews »
Get the February, 2012 issue of
Atomic
mailed to you for
$8.95
, including postage.
Subscribe
Buy now
Digital Version
Please enable JavaScript to view the
comments powered by Disqus.