CPUs, Motherboards & RAM
Graphics Cards
Peripherals
Modding & Cooling
Systems
Networking
Security
Operating Systems
PC Games
Console Games
Atomic.edu
Tutorials
Lifestyle
Entertainment
Science
Wallpapers
Revolver Melbourne 2011
Revolver Sydney 2011
Atomic Unlocked 2010
Power to the PC Tour 2010
Industry Events
Login
|
Register
|
RSS
News
|
Reviews
|
Features
|
User Reviews
|
Galleries
|
Videos
|
Competitions
|
Newsletter
|
Subscribe
Thursday May 24, 2012 2:17 PM AEST
Atomic MPC
>
Group Tests
>
Build
>
Graphics Cards
>
Sub-$250 graphics cards
Graphics Cards
Sub-$250 graphics cards
By
Justin Robinson
17:07 Feb 18, 2009
|
5 Comments
Tags:
video
|
cards
|
budget
|
gaming
Tweet
«
1 - Introduction.
2 - Feeds, speeds and results.
3 - Conclusion.
Products Tested
Elitegroup 8800GT
94%
Foxconn 9600GT
92%
Gigabyte 9800GT
91%
EVGA 9500GT
55%
HIS 4670 IceQ
85%
Sapphire 4830
89%
GIGABYTE HD4650 1GB
55%
Zotac 9400GT ZONE Edition
72%
Sapphire HD4650
80%
Sapphire 4550
65%
Zotac 9500GT Zone Edition
83%
So, which one won?
If one were studious enough in their observation of the graphs, you’d have noticed something quite interesting about the value of each of these cards. You’d also notice, of course, the performance. But what does this all mean, and how is this going to help you decide which card you’re going to buy next? Well, we’ve made some categories to give you that extra edge when taking the final plunge.
Best Performance
Win:
GIGABYTE 9800GT
Nearly-win:
Elitegroup 8800GT
It goes without saying that in this roundup, there has been one card at the top of the deck throughout the entire time. The Gigabyte 9800GT was able to pull ahead in every single test, giving us the best performance, with a very good amount of memory, cooling and overclocking headroom. Not only that, but it looks rather interesting too!
This one isn’t the best in terms of value, nor is it the best for your buck, but if you do grab this one you’ll be very happy and secure in the knowledge that you’ve got the fastest budget card out right now – period.
Bang ‘fer ‘yer Buck
Win:
Foxconn 9600GT
Nearly-win:
Elitegroup 8800GT
Apart from a Fallout 3-induced momentary lapse of correct Australian journalistic accent, this category will give you the highest amount of 3DMark06 points for each dollar you spend. Essentially, you’re going to be getting the best increase in performance for your hard-earned – and that is definitely a good thing. Keep in mind that while this won’t necessarily give you the highest performance, however.
The card of choice in this category is the Foxconn 9600GT. Giving you 73.63 3DMark06 points for every dollar you spend, there really isn’t another card that is as good value, making this one an excellent choice. And not only that, but it’s also a decent card for gaming too, and perfect for a LANning rig.
Best Overall Value
Win:
Elitegroup 8800GT
Nearly-win:
Foxconn 9600GT
Our last category is Value. This isn’t quite the same as getting the best performance, nor is it the same as bang for your buck, but rather the amount of awesome stuff you get for the cash outlaid. We’ve picked the Elitegroup 8800GT, because you get the second-highest performance AND bang for your buck, AND you get a very good game included – all for only $175. You really can’t beat this amount of value, and if we were to recommend any of these cards on an overall weighting, this would definitely be the one to pick.
Through all of our benching, testing, calculating, plotting, scheming and dreaming, we’ve pretty quantitatively shown that the lower end cards are really not worth considering if you call yourself an enthusiast. Depending on your needs, there’s going to be something here for you – and if you want to kick it up a notch in performance, make sure you check out the upcoming issues of Atomic for all the latest and greatest graphics reviews – there’s some exciting cards on the horizon.
«
1 - Introduction.
2 - Feeds, speeds and results.
3 - Conclusion.
This article appeared in the
January 09
issue of Atomic.
Aliens: Colonial Marines in depth; Z-77 Motherboard round-up; strategy gaming special; Home Server tutorial. PLUS MUCH MORE - ON SALE NOW!
Email this
Print this
Tweet this
Send us your tips
Ads by Google
5 Comments
cleadge
Feb 18, 2009 6:31 PM
i think thar is a typo in the first chart "3dMark06 points per dollar - [b]lower[/b] is better."
azn_warez
Feb 18, 2009 9:05 PM
I thought the HD4850 can be had for $240 right?
heydude
Feb 19, 2009 11:36 AM
No mention of power requirements???
The ati 4670 does not even need any external power connector and pulls those frame rates, pretty impressive.
And the card can run on a crappy psu.
Not to mention its stellar power reduction in windows,
it drops to 165mhz gpu clock and 250mhz mem clock in
windows dropping power requirements for a trully green
card that can game as well.
Well if I spent that much time on reviewing these cards
I think I would have mentioned that.
Not to mention that the his version comes with a brilliant
cooler that exhuasts the heat out the back of the case.
TheFrunj
Feb 20, 2009 11:06 AM
Hi heydude,
While we'd have certainly liked to have included power measurements for the budget-skewed angle, we actually didn't think of it at the time. However there is a handy thread on the forums that does list the power draw of those cards:
http://forums.atomicmpc.com.au/index.php?showtopic=264
*makes mental note to get power meter for next budget roundup*
-JR
heydude
Feb 20, 2009 12:57 PM
Thanks TheFrunj, I mentioned it because we always hear of how power efficient cpu's are, but in something like graphics that reasoning generally goes out the window for some strange reason. Must be frame rates, lol.
Cheers.
Comments have been disabled on this article.
Shogun 2: Total War – The Fall of the Samurai
Diablo III Review - it's good, but it will make you rage...
Nvidia 'Big Kepler' GK-110 Announced for Supercomputers
Is a bad launch the end of the world? And if not... why?
Blizzard to fans: "we want to sincerely apologize"
Powered by Disqus
Atomic Magazine
Issue:
137
|
June, 2012
Atomic
is a magazine aimed squarely at computer enthusiasts, gamers, and serious PC upgraders.
Every month we bring you the latest reviews of new technology and PC components, in depth features on everything from overclocking to console hacking, and gaming previews and interviews.
What's in this issue?
Subscribe Now
Latest Comments
Powered by Disqus
Latest User Reviews
90%
Battlefield 3 is the new benchmark online FPS
A very fun and realistic multiplayer ride.
By
Periander
|
10:59 Nov 20, 2011
90%
Antec Kuhler 920 - liquid cool
Antec Kuhler 920 silent but effientive out of the box no maintence water cooling kit
By
mattleyland
|
14:23 Oct 28, 2011
90%
Antec's Lanboy Air - our new favourite case
Antec Lan boy Air in red a very cool design
By
mattleyland
|
12:55 Oct 28, 2011
90%
Antec's Lanboy Air - our new favourite case
This product overall is awesome.
By
Provodnik14
|
10:43 Oct 16, 2011
90%
MSI's GT780 laptop as fast as it gets
Nice laptop
By
daryl.cheshire
|
00:53 Oct 4, 2011
more user reviews »